Good Beef Comes to Those Who Wait
2-min read
Nicole (our Customer Service Manager) was recently out for a couple of days.
Which meant I was on phone answering duty.....
We use one of those call apps so multiple people can man the phones, and normally Nicole handles about 95% of incoming calls. She's very good at her job. I am... fine at it.
But a few days back in the mix reminded me of some important things.
First, we get a ton of calls. This still blows my mind. For years, getting a phone call was so rare I just listed my personal cell number and was usually caught off guard when it was a customer. Then we went viral, and I talked so much I literally lost my voice, and we hired Nicole and apparently the calls never stopped.
Second, the whole Beef Share thing remains genuinely unusual for the average person who hasn't been fully indoctrinated yet.
Things I take completely for granted apparently sound insane to someone who just found us on the internet.
Exhibit A: The Waitlist
Several people I talked to were a little flummoxed by the whole "give money to a farmer you met on the internet and then wait three months for beef" situation.
And honestly, when they put it to me that way... I had to admit it has a certain Nigerian Prince vibe going on.
But I defy you to find one of those princes with 150+ five-star Google reviews!
Anyway....
We have absolutely become an instant gratification society
You place an order and expect it in two days. Amazon has rewired our brains. I get it.
But that instant gratification comes with real tradeoffs.
The beef at your grocery store is "instant" because it's been "wet-aging" its way through a massive supply chain for weeks (yum). Butcher Box can ship on demand because they are importing entire shipping containers of mediocre gamey beef from Australia.
Why dry aging matters (and why dry aged grass fed beef requires patience)
Real dry aged grass fed beef can't be rushed. The whole reason it tastes like beef instead of pink water is that we hang the carcass in a cooler for weeks and let enzymes break down the muscle fibers and concentrate the flavor. Moisture evaporates. Funk develops. Steaks get tender. You can't shortcut that with two-day shipping. The waitlist is what makes it possible.
That's also why the beef on a grocery store shelf is sealed wet in plastic. It's the cheap way: "age" the meat in its own juices in a cryovac bag while it slowly works its way across the country. (More on why that beef ends up watery here.)
So I come before you, humbly, to preach the many merits of the Waitlist
For us, it allows us to plan our harvests, shipments, and so on, well in advance. Which is the kind of competitive advantage a small farm needs to do things right and compete in this day and age.
This is obviously great for us, but it's not a one sided deal.
For you, it means that you are getting THE BEST of the best. We never send an animal to the butcher if we don't feel it is perfectly finished and ready. In return for your trust and patience, we are going to fill your freezer with the best beef you've ever eaten and have you thanking "past you" every single time you cook some up.
That is our standard, and it's only possible thanks to our amazing customers who embrace the somewhat odd way we do things. (For the full version of why we do it this way, see the B.E.E.F. System.)
Slow beef vs. instant beef, plainly
| What you get | Grocery store / box-store beef | Dirty Dog Farm |
|---|---|---|
| Aging method | Wet-aged in plastic during shipping | Dry-aged in our butcher's cooler |
| Time from harvest to your freezer | Weeks to months across a national supply chain | A few weeks of intentional aging, then direct to you |
| Animal selection | Whatever the supply chain produced this week | Only animals we feel are perfectly finished |
| Ordering | Order today, eat today | Reserve a spot, wait a few months, eat the best beef of your life |
Reserve your spot for the June harvests
Speaking of the waitlist, we are already reserving shares for our June harvests!
So if you want to be grilling the best tasting, most nourishing, 100% Grass Fed Beef in existence all summer long, it's time to put down your deposit (it's fully refundable btw) and claim your spot......
Reserve your next Beef Share here.
Not sure which share size fits your household? Take our 60-second beef share quiz before you put down a deposit.
Your Farmer,
Josh
P.S. It's 80º and I am kicking myself for not finishing all my winter office projects a month ago. This is cowboyin' weather, and yet I am forced to submit loan documentation.
More Recommended Reading
Why We'll Never Be the Next ButcherBox (And Why...
Dirty Dog Farm vs ButcherBox: a customer asked if we want to be the next...
Why We'll Never Be the Next ButcherBox (And Why...
Dirty Dog Farm vs ButcherBox: a customer asked if we want to be the next...
How a Small Grass Fed Beef Farm Becomes a Beef ...
A financial reporter called us up to talk cattle prices. By the end of the...
How a Small Grass Fed Beef Farm Becomes a Beef ...
A financial reporter called us up to talk cattle prices. By the end of the...
How to Get the Benefits of Organ Meat Without E...
Everyone knows liver is good for them. Almost nobody wants to cook it. Primal Blend...
How to Get the Benefits of Organ Meat Without E...
Everyone knows liver is good for them. Almost nobody wants to cook it. Primal Blend...
Why Is There a Wait List for Beef Shares? (And ...
There is no backlog, no beef sitting in storage, and no extra shift at the...
Why Is There a Wait List for Beef Shares? (And ...
There is no backlog, no beef sitting in storage, and no extra shift at the...
Do People Actually Reorder Beef Shares? (Meet a...
William is placing his third order and second whole cow. Here's why returning customers are...
Do People Actually Reorder Beef Shares? (Meet a...
William is placing his third order and second whole cow. Here's why returning customers are...
Good Beef Comes to Those Who Wait
Why our waitlist exists, why it actually benefits you, and how dry aged grass fed...
Good Beef Comes to Those Who Wait
Why our waitlist exists, why it actually benefits you, and how dry aged grass fed...
2-min read
We Confess: We Orchestrated the 300,000 Ton Bee...
A full confession to founding a fake lobbying group, sabotaging Argentina's beef exports, and timing...
We Confess: We Orchestrated the 300,000 Ton Bee...
A full confession to founding a fake lobbying group, sabotaging Argentina's beef exports, and timing...
2-min read
How Many Cattle Does a Slaughterhouse Process P...
A single Big 4 slaughterhouse processes up to 10,000 head of cattle a day. Our...
How Many Cattle Does a Slaughterhouse Process P...
A single Big 4 slaughterhouse processes up to 10,000 head of cattle a day. Our...
2-min read
Why Is the US Importing 300,000 More Tons of Be...
Quotas were lifted to allow an extra 300,000 tons of imported beef this year. A...
Why Is the US Importing 300,000 More Tons of Be...
Quotas were lifted to allow an extra 300,000 tons of imported beef this year. A...
2-min read
The Unoptimizable Secret to Great Beef (Why We ...
What makes great beef isn't a hack, a breed, or a gadget. It's time. Here's...
The Unoptimizable Secret to Great Beef (Why We ...
What makes great beef isn't a hack, a breed, or a gadget. It's time. Here's...
2-min read
First Cut vs. Second Cut Hay (And Why It Matter...
First cut is the tall stemmy spring growth. Second cut is the leafier, higher-protein regrowth...
First Cut vs. Second Cut Hay (And Why It Matter...
First cut is the tall stemmy spring growth. Second cut is the leafier, higher-protein regrowth...
2-min read
Annual Prepper Mode: Why Smart Families Stock T...
On a farm, being unprepared for winter is miserable. Here's why we go full prepper...
Annual Prepper Mode: Why Smart Families Stock T...
On a farm, being unprepared for winter is miserable. Here's why we go full prepper...
2-min read
Why Are Feedlot Steers Lactating? (15-19% of Th...
Research on cattle from large feedlots found 15-19% of steers actively lactating. A farmer walks...
Why Are Feedlot Steers Lactating? (15-19% of Th...
Research on cattle from large feedlots found 15-19% of steers actively lactating. A farmer walks...
We Ruined a Dinner Party (And We're Not Sorry)
A customer's dinner party went silent after he served our chuck roast. The grass fed...
We Ruined a Dinner Party (And We're Not Sorry)
A customer's dinner party went silent after he served our chuck roast. The grass fed...
2-min read
We Have a Confession to Make (About Small Farm ...
A satirical confession about small farm growth, perpetual global crisis, and why our beef share...
We Have a Confession to Make (About Small Farm ...
A satirical confession about small farm growth, perpetual global crisis, and why our beef share...
2-min read
We Obtained Big Beef's Leaked Q3 Memo (Satire, ...
A satirical internal memo from the Protein Velocity Division, delivered by a suspiciously scaly figure...
We Obtained Big Beef's Leaked Q3 Memo (Satire, ...
A satirical internal memo from the Protein Velocity Division, delivered by a suspiciously scaly figure...
2-min read
Why Are Cattle Slaughtered So Much Younger Than...
In 1977 the average American beef steer lived about 21 months. Today it's under 16....
Why Are Cattle Slaughtered So Much Younger Than...
In 1977 the average American beef steer lived about 21 months. Today it's under 16....
Can 100% Grass-Fed Beef Actually Be Well Marble...
Most people assume grass-fed beef is lean and tough. Here's why properly finished 100% grass-fed...
Can 100% Grass-Fed Beef Actually Be Well Marble...
Most people assume grass-fed beef is lean and tough. Here's why properly finished 100% grass-fed...
The Great Bull Escape of 2026 (And What It Taug...
Two breeding bulls vanished, walked two miles through the woods, and turned up in a...
The Great Bull Escape of 2026 (And What It Taug...
Two breeding bulls vanished, walked two miles through the woods, and turned up in a...
Cows Are Basically a Plant-Based Food (A Farmer...
A vegetarian sent us fan mail about our burgers. Here's what we hear from former...
Cows Are Basically a Plant-Based Food (A Farmer...
A vegetarian sent us fan mail about our burgers. Here's what we hear from former...
Where to Buy 100% Grass-Fed Beef Organs (And Wh...
Our farm ran an organ black market by text message for years. Here's why the...
Where to Buy 100% Grass-Fed Beef Organs (And Wh...
Our farm ran an organ black market by text message for years. Here's why the...
2-min read
Why a Full Freezer of Beef Benefits Every Part ...
The freezer full of beef benefits aren't just about meals: it shifts how you cook,...
Why a Full Freezer of Beef Benefits Every Part ...
The freezer full of beef benefits aren't just about meals: it shifts how you cook,...
2-min read
What Hauling a Cow Actually Looks Like (And How...
How grass fed cattle are transported, from a farmer who genuinely loves hauling but stresses...
What Hauling a Cow Actually Looks Like (And How...
How grass fed cattle are transported, from a farmer who genuinely loves hauling but stresses...
2-min read
Why Big Beef Brands Get Away With Selling You W...
A true story about a meat subscription that wouldn't stop shipping to the wrong house,...
Why Big Beef Brands Get Away With Selling You W...
A true story about a meat subscription that wouldn't stop shipping to the wrong house,...
2-min read
What Does "100% Grass Fed" Actually Mean? (The ...
A cattle trucker offered us 50 beautiful grass-fed steers. Then he mentioned the bread. Here's...
What Does "100% Grass Fed" Actually Mean? (The ...
A cattle trucker offered us 50 beautiful grass-fed steers. Then he mentioned the bread. Here's...
2-min read
We're Beef Men: Inside a Cattle-Dealing Day at ...
How grass fed cattle are sourced when you're a small farm trying to scale the...
We're Beef Men: Inside a Cattle-Dealing Day at ...
How grass fed cattle are sourced when you're a small farm trying to scale the...
2-min read
Why a Full Freezer Is the Ultimate Chaos Insura...
A busy Monday of liner-truck ambushes and escaped bulls turned into the clearest sales pitch...
Why a Full Freezer Is the Ultimate Chaos Insura...
A busy Monday of liner-truck ambushes and escaped bulls turned into the clearest sales pitch...
2-min read
What the Federal Reserve Said About Beef Prices...
A farmer's plain-English read on the Fed's beef price data, why grocery beef keeps getting...
What the Federal Reserve Said About Beef Prices...
A farmer's plain-English read on the Fed's beef price data, why grocery beef keeps getting...
2-min read
Does Stressed Cattle Actually Change How Beef T...
A grass-fed beef farmer's takeaways from a Temple Grandin workshop on why stressed cattle produce...
Does Stressed Cattle Actually Change How Beef T...
A grass-fed beef farmer's takeaways from a Temple Grandin workshop on why stressed cattle produce...
2-min read
Life, Death, and Beef: What It Means to Raise a...
Ethical grass fed beef means caring for an animal you know you're going to eat....
Life, Death, and Beef: What It Means to Raise a...
Ethical grass fed beef means caring for an animal you know you're going to eat....
2-min read
I Ate Grain-Fed Beef for the First Time in Year...
A grass-fed beef farmer takes a vacation, eats a corn-fed ribeye at a hotel restaurant,...
I Ate Grain-Fed Beef for the First Time in Year...
A grass-fed beef farmer takes a vacation, eats a corn-fed ribeye at a hotel restaurant,...
How to Tell If Your Beef Is Actually Good (You ...
How to tell if beef is good quality when the labels lie, the supply chains...
How to Tell If Your Beef Is Actually Good (You ...
How to tell if beef is good quality when the labels lie, the supply chains...
2-min read
Which Beef Share Fits in an Apartment Freezer? ...
No room for a chest freezer? The Mini Beef Share is 20 pounds of 100%...
Which Beef Share Fits in an Apartment Freezer? ...
No room for a chest freezer? The Mini Beef Share is 20 pounds of 100%...
2-min read
50 Steers Walk Into a Farm: The Biggest Swing o...
We started with 7 cows and hauled bathtub water through a Vermont winter. This spring...
50 Steers Walk Into a Farm: The Biggest Swing o...
We started with 7 cows and hauled bathtub water through a Vermont winter. This spring...
2-min read
The Investment Case for Buying Beef in Bulk
A customer recently called his beef share "one of the best investments I've ever made."...
The Investment Case for Buying Beef in Bulk
A customer recently called his beef share "one of the best investments I've ever made."...
2-min read
Why Is Beef So Expensive Right Now? A Farmer Ex...
Grocery store beef just hit an all-time high, up 16% in a year. A grass-fed...
Why Is Beef So Expensive Right Now? A Farmer Ex...
Grocery store beef just hit an all-time high, up 16% in a year. A grass-fed...
2-min read
Why BBQ Sauce Is Ruining Your Beef
If you're slathering BBQ sauce on grass fed beef, you're covering up the actual reason...
Why BBQ Sauce Is Ruining Your Beef
If you're slathering BBQ sauce on grass fed beef, you're covering up the actual reason...
2-min read
What's Actually In Grocery Store Ground Beef (A...
A grass-fed beef farmer on what 'ground beef' actually means at the grocery store, and...
What's Actually In Grocery Store Ground Beef (A...
A grass-fed beef farmer on what 'ground beef' actually means at the grocery store, and...
Burdening Future Generations: Why a Small Farm ...
A farmer replaces a gate post with maximum overkill and explains why small farms building...
Burdening Future Generations: Why a Small Farm ...
A farmer replaces a gate post with maximum overkill and explains why small farms building...
2-min read
How Regenerative Grazing Builds Soil That Beats...
A grass-fed beef farmer on how regenerative grazing builds drought-resistant soil, deep grass roots, and...
How Regenerative Grazing Builds Soil That Beats...
A grass-fed beef farmer on how regenerative grazing builds drought-resistant soil, deep grass roots, and...
2-min read
Meet the Big 4 Meatpackers: A Farmer's Guide to...
JBS, Cargill, Tyson, National Beef. A grass-fed beef farmer explains who the Big 4 Meatpackers...
Meet the Big 4 Meatpackers: A Farmer's Guide to...
JBS, Cargill, Tyson, National Beef. A grass-fed beef farmer explains who the Big 4 Meatpackers...
Teaching Kids to Cook: Why I Let My 3-Year-Old ...
Modern life is obsessed with making everything frictionless. Here is why I think that is...
Teaching Kids to Cook: Why I Let My 3-Year-Old ...
Modern life is obsessed with making everything frictionless. Here is why I think that is...
2-min read
What Size Freezer Do You Need for a Quarter, Ha...
What size freezer do you need for a quarter cow, half cow, or whole cow?...
What Size Freezer Do You Need for a Quarter, Ha...
What size freezer do you need for a quarter cow, half cow, or whole cow?...
2-min read
Glyphosate Now Has Extra Legal Protection: A Fa...
The Supreme Court ruled in favor of Bayer-Monsanto, stripping states of the power to require...
Glyphosate Now Has Extra Legal Protection: A Fa...
The Supreme Court ruled in favor of Bayer-Monsanto, stripping states of the power to require...
2-min read
Larder-Maxxing: Why Stocking Your Freezer Beats...
Larder maxxing is the old-school answer to the modern wellness circus: stock up a few...
Larder-Maxxing: Why Stocking Your Freezer Beats...
Larder maxxing is the old-school answer to the modern wellness circus: stock up a few...
2-min read
Hay Season Launch Party: Why the Day We Cut Hay...
Why the narrow harvest window for clover-rich pasture matters, why a small grass-fed beef farm...
Hay Season Launch Party: Why the Day We Cut Hay...
Why the narrow harvest window for clover-rich pasture matters, why a small grass-fed beef farm...
2-min read
The Longest Rap Sheet in the Meat Business (Ins...
Bribery, child labor, price-fixing, lied antibiotic-free claims, illegal Amazon deforestation: a grass-fed beef farmer breaks...
The Longest Rap Sheet in the Meat Business (Ins...
Bribery, child labor, price-fixing, lied antibiotic-free claims, illegal Amazon deforestation: a grass-fed beef farmer breaks...
2-min read
Is All Grass-Fed Beef the Same? (No. Here's Why...
A farmer breaks down why pasture and hay diversity (and a 72-year-old customer's 'beef from...
Is All Grass-Fed Beef the Same? (No. Here's Why...
A farmer breaks down why pasture and hay diversity (and a 72-year-old customer's 'beef from...
2-min read
Why Are American Farms Disappearing? (77 Per Da...
America has lost 150,000 farms this decade, or 77 per day. A grass-fed beef farmer...
Why Are American Farms Disappearing? (77 Per Da...
America has lost 150,000 farms this decade, or 77 per day. A grass-fed beef farmer...
2-min read
Should a Small Farm Own Its Own Butcher? (Or: W...
A grass-fed beef farmer on why partnering with expert butchers beats vertically integrating, plus a...
Should a Small Farm Own Its Own Butcher? (Or: W...
A grass-fed beef farmer on why partnering with expert butchers beats vertically integrating, plus a...